Proactiv MD vs Proactiv Original: How to Pick the Right One for Your Skin Type

proactiv md vs proactiv solution

Disclosure: This post may include affiliate links. This means we may get a commission if you visit the links on our site and make a purchase. 

Proactiv is not an unknown name in the world of acne treatment. In fact, it has established quite an impressive reputation since the launch of the original Proactiv Solution several years ago.

Then, they continued to build on the effective formula, which saw a slightly improved version of the original solution in the Proactiv Plus.

But with their latest addition to the collection, Proactiv MD, the approach is significantly different and definitely worth looking at in more detail.

As an interesting side-note, the Proactiv range was developed by two dermatologists who are really passionate about their work. Katie Rodan, M.D. and Kathy Fields have won awards for their contribution to the field of skin care and treating acne, so there is definite substance behind their theories.

And with this knowledge in mind, here is our take on which Proactiv product is the better choice.

Is Proactiv MD or Proactiv Original Better?

When looking at all the details and user experiences, Proactiv MD comes out the winner. And it’s not surprising, seeing as this is the latest formula by the Proactiv line.

But that doesn’t mean the original Proactiv Solution should be thrown out completely.

Keeping in mind that everyone has a different skin type, the active ingredient in the original formula could be more effective. Hence the reason for this detailed Proactiv MD Vs. Proactiv Solution comparison.

Because if nothing else, we want you to make the most informed decision possible.

1. Proactiv MD

Price: See Current Price at Proactiv Website

the proactiv md 3 step acne fighting system is a great option for adults

The active ingredient for the Proactiv MD formula is Adapalene, which is a fairly big difference when compared to benzoyl peroxide, the active ingredient for Proactiv Solution.

And up until recently, it was impossible to get a formula with the Adapalene ingredient without a prescription.

That makes Proactiv MD (read my testimonial)  the first over-the-counter acne treatment with this powerful retinoid derivative.

As mentioned earlier, this is the latest formula from the Proactiv developers, and they placed a lot of focus on addressing certain issues.

For example, the original formula can be somewhat aggressive in terms of drying out the skin, whereas Adapalene doesn’t have such intense side-effects. And at the same time, it brings about incredible results for light to mild acne breakouts.

How it Works

proactiv md body moisturizer

The formula is broken into 4 steps, namely:

Step 1: Deep Cleansing Face Wash

Get rid of excess oil, dirt, dead skin cells, and everything else that makes your pores clog up and cause a breakout. In the face wash, you’ll feel tiny beads, specifically for a gentle yet deep scrub.

Step 2: Balancing Toner

It is important that the skin stays healthy during acne treatment, which is why the toner provides critical nutrients for restoring the PH balance.

Step 3: Daily Control Moisturizer (SPF 30)

Protect your skin from sun rays without clogging pores thanks to the Daily Control Moisturizer. You can use it whenever you feel it necessary.

Step 4: Adapalene Gel 0.1%

This is the magic ingredient that helps you gain control over acne outbreaks.

Using the system is incredibly easy.

Basically, you go through the first two steps and let your skin dry. Step 3 can be used throughout the day, and step 4 is only applied once a day.

Ultimately, the system aims to give you healthy and glowing skin, while the active ingredient clears out your pores.

Key Acne-Fighting Ingredients

It is obvious by now that Adapalene is the main acne-fighting ingredient within the Proactiv MD formula.

It should also be noted that children under the age of 12 should speak to a dermatologist first.

But there are supportive ingredients that make the active ingredient more effective, like the Avobenzone (3%), octisalate (5%), and octocrylene (7%) that can be found in the Daily Oil Control (Step 3).

Why is Proactiv MD the Best Choice for People with Acne?

First off, the clinical proof is in the pudding. Even the experts agree that Adapalene is incredibly effective. At the same time, it is not a miracle cure.

Instead, you are looking at a subtle way of clearing acne breakouts while taking care of your skin. It is not the type of formula you need to apply several times a day, and it can easily be implemented with a life on the go.

So for those with light to mild acne breakouts, it is worth trying Proactiv MD.

Where Can You Get the Best Proactiv MD Deal?

You can find the best deal on Proactiv MD from the website directly.

Don’t risk using a third party, which can be more expensive and possibly sell you some knock-off products. Stick to the official site if you want to make sure you’re locking in their very best deal!

Right now is a great time get great savings on Proactiv MD:

2. Proactiv Solution (Original)

Price: See Current Price at Proactiv Website

Proactiv Solution

The Proactiv Solution made waves when it first hit the market, and just like with their latest product, the developers depended on a clinically proven active ingredient.

However, it wasn’t without its faults. For example, the dryness caused by the active ingredient made the developers come up with the toners and moisturizers, which aid in curbing the side-effects.

How it Works

There are only three steps for the Proactiv Solution system, and they are:

Step 1: Renewing Cleanser

The first step is about prepping your skin with the cleanser.

Step 2: Revitalizing Toner

The toner restores valuable nutrients.

Step 3: Repairing Treatment

The final step will see the active ingredient effectively fighting the acne breakout.

You need to follow all three steps in the morning, and in the evening. And to support the active ingredient, the toner is alcohol-free.

Key Acne-Fighting Ingredients

Both Step 1 and Step 3 contain the key ingredient, which is Benzoyl Peroxide, 2.5%. As for Step 2, it contains glycolic acid, sodium hydroxide, and witch hazel extract for helping the skin to retain a natural PH balance.

Who Should Consider Proactiv Solution?

Even though the original Proactiv formula is overshadowed by the latest addition, there are still people who use it.

For example, Benzoyl Peroxide is more aggressive than Adapalene, so you might see results quicker.

But the side-effects are more intense and irritating, hence the reason for users switching to the MD alternative.

But if you don’t have very sensitive skin, you can definitely try the original solution if you prefer.

Where Can You Get the Best Proactiv Solution Deal?

Just as recommended with Proactiv MD, go to the official site. They have special memberships you can join to make fighting acne more affordable, and you are not going to get this option through a third-party.

Comparison Summary: Our Tip Pick?

free proactiv acne scrub brush

When it comes down to it, we choose to put our trust in the Proactiv MD before trying the original Proactiv Solution.

And we are not saying this product is the perfect solution, but it has a less aggressive approach for getting the same results – if not better.

Just like with the original formula, there are side-effects to consider, and you might need an additional moisturizer if you have really sensitive skin.

But saying that everyone will agree with this comparison is simply not realistic. Variables like age and skin-type can make a big difference when you are searching for an effective solution.

In fact, there might be individuals who might not be satisfied at all.

This is because you should approach every product with realistic expectations. And for the most part, the active ingredients for both MD and Solution have proven to work for thousands.

But it’s our personal opinion to try Proactiv MD first.

Ready to Finally Say Goodbye to Your Acne?